Showing posts with label Economic Justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Economic Justice. Show all posts

4.19.2015

Crime and Punishment - based on The Crisis of Imprisonment by Rebecca M. McLennan (2008)

Moving away from the journey of enslaved Africans in American towards Emancipation, Rebecca McLennan's book The Crisis of Imprisonment: Protest, Politics and the Making of the American Penal State, 1776-1941 (2008) traces the long history of convicts towards an abolition of their own. The U.S. penal system developed distinctly from the sanguinary, capital punishment system of Europe. In American taxonomy, a convict is inferior to the free laborer, and thus subjected to the intense "other-ing" that is endemic to our nation. Yet, even as convicts, their keepers and the general public sought to create institutions worthy of our founding ideals - even for the lowest classes in society - the convict class itself was stratified by race, gender, ethnicity and sexual orientation for generations, thus unnecessarily prolonging the path of reformation and intensifying the crisis within our prisons.

After the signing of the Declaration of Independence, new Americans had an ideology, a moral compass, to guide them in the business of empire-building. Freedom of choice, religion, the right to work and to participate in the fledgling democracy led the U.S. to call into question the legitimacy of European criminal institutions and treatment. Should life and death be in the hands of one, or even a few persons? The United States was not a monarchy or a dictatorship, as this interfered with the freedoms fought for in the new republic. Instead, the principle of proportionality was adopted early on, forcing prisoners to pay for their crimes to society with their time rather than their lives. In 1786, lawmakers began to experiment with deterrence theory, which favored a system of hard convict labor over that of capital punishment (33). The ensuing "wheelbarrow men" as the laboring convicts were dubbed, were quickly deemed "weak, failing, unrepublican and ugly" (35). As criticism and derision against the public spectacle of the wheelbarrow men intensified, the "house of repentance," today's penitentiary, came into view (36). The goal was not to goad prisoners into further criminal acts (as the mockery of the wheelbarrow men proved most useful for), but to compel a convict to submit to "soul surgery" and examine the consequences of previous decisions, while simultaneously keeping the general public at bay and in the dark as to what conditions convicts were subjected to within prison walls.

The penitentiary system was more humane than its predecessor, but negligible as to if it was more ethical or efficacious. Although servitude - involuntary or otherwise - was progressively frowned upon over the course of the nineteenth century, state government began to push hard, productive labor after 1830, which led to the contract prison labor system, under which convict labor was sold to private interests (54). Nonetheless, keepers and prison officials were keen to recognize a "relationship of dependency" (72) between convict and personnel. It behooved officials to treat convicts with dignity and respect. This realization paved the way for the field of penology to flourish during the Gilded Age and the early Progressive era, up to the country's decision to enter the Great War in 1917. The new convict was a "man" and socialized (gendered) to be a better man upon release. At times, this path of reformation was impeded by private interests, or public perception. It was always hindered by the racist and sexist notions of the eras, as women and blacks were routinely excluded from  - or extensively delayed the benefits of - reform by custom and law.

In connecting this text with the larger themes of citizenship and freedom from this semester's canon of historiography, McLennan skillfully portrays the convict as an "other" much like the enslaved or freed black American, whose livelihood, and democratic potential was in the hands of (other) white men. Several times she discusses the abolition of the contract prison labor system, or of socializing convicts to eventually fit the ideal of manhood, much in the way historians have pieced together white male perceptions of the black experience up to and beyond Emancipation. This verbiage necessitates a deeper read of the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments, as convicts are explicitly excluded from being full citizens, having the right to vote, and being free from slavery by any other name. This denial of democracy underscores the "other-ing" of convicts as now their history can be examined with methods similar to those used to flesh out the black experience in America.

McLennan focuses on the New York state penal system throughout the text, as New York was primed for reform with the established prisons at Auburn, Clinton and Sing Sing, as well as the melodrama of Tammany Hall, a New York political organization that produced several influential politicians who in turn produced several influential wardens. Outside of New York, McLennan tells of the status of prisons in other industrial states north of the Mason-Dixon line. This strengthens her narrative that hard, productive labor in industrial sectors propelled penal reforms. While Southern carceral patterns are introduced, they are not given the same exposure in McLennan's book. By including Southern penal institutions, McLennan would have been forced to step away from America's Industrial Revolution and center her research on the racism and sexism that plagued the South as evidenced in last week's read on the "problem South." For what the South lacked in legal, economic, social and public health advances, one can imagine McLennan's book as a very different text had Southern penal history been a larger part.
Despite America's history of enslavement of African Americans, in the 21st century Black prisoners in the Deep South were forced to pick cotton on former plantations or face disciplinary punishment. The 13th Amenment's prohibition on slavery expressly does not apply to incarcerated people. Pictured, prisoners at Parchman State Prison in Mississippi in 1996. (source: Twitter on 15 April 2015)
Eventually, McLennan shows that during the High Progressive era, penologists inspired by Thomas Mott Osborne used Sing Sing as a test case for a smorgasbord of social reforms intended to include the convict and understand his condition and proclivity to crime. It was during this time that prisoners formed internal democracies, circulated periodicals, formed intramural athletic leagues and undertook financial literacy training and general education courses. Under the ministrations of penal psychiatrist Bernard Glueck, strides were made in documenting and organizing data, especially that which lead an academic inquiry into the nature of homosexuality in prisons and the epidemiology of sexually transmitted diseases. On the watch of the "new penologists," prisoners received specialized health care (and "other-ing") for diagnoses of STDs and mental infirmities. Whereas Foucault argued that work gangs yielded the prison system, McLennan's argument is that the move from hard, productive, for-profit convict labor necessitated the modern penal institution. The new penology focused on the whole convict and not the capacity that was profitable. Both are correct in that work gangs were not a lasting solution, as convicts are people that cannot be reduced to beasts of burden. As rehabilitation became the only viable solution, the nature of the American penal system had to give. It's first steps are documented well in this text.

McLennan's book was extremely easy to read, although I admit to tiring of the word "crisis" used redundantly throughout. In the Acknowledgments, McLennan states that the book "originated as a doctoral dissertation and....matured as a book manuscript" (xi) before, over some time, it was published. My only critique is that the book lacks continuity, as within each chapter, I felt the need to wade through the redundant terms and information before getting to the argument at hand. I could tell that the author had developed this tome over time and as independent pieces; well done in that regard. She left no stone unturned in her patient dissection of this long history. McLennan is precise, thorough and efficient in her wrtiing. Her perspective is hers alone and represents a unique voice in the scholarship on penological reform in industrial America.


~ dls

2.15.2015

Humanity Held Captive: Slavery and the Numbers Game by Stanley Gutman (1975)

As an economist, my discipline routinely asks that I quantify human decisions. Often that takes the form of buying and selling "goods," but what of buying and selling "bads?" There's a host of data driven media that examines "black market" activities. Weighing the benefits and costs of buying and selling drugs, guns or women is debated in absolute or relative figures, graphed, converted into rates and logarithms, imputed, and very often stratified by demographic such as gender, race, age and education level. By convention, economists do not personify this data as a historian would; the numbers tell the story. It goes without saying that these are sensitive subjects, as many people have been affected by street, drug or sexual violence, but the economic analysis of these modern taboo markets is designed to make assumptions to homogenize the persons demanding and supplying these goods. This makes data more tractable for econometric methods to state conclusions about the value of legalization or, of a life.

An economist who examines the past with such quantitative methods has a different set of challenges, however. In America, black markets in the antebellum period were likely black people. And while black Americans are no longer enslaved, there persists a communal memory of the years of acute social struggle as evidenced through public commemorations of Black History Month and Juneteenth, and private conversations between the generations. There also exists a desire to quantify the cost of slavery so as to hold the federal government accountable to allocate reparations in the form of cash or in-kind services to descendants of slaves, such as education or asset building opportunities. Today, the agency and humanity of a black American is uncontested by the definition, evidence and interpretation of the "black experience," the three levels proposed by Micheal Trotti with which to confront challenging trends in racial literature (375). But the agency and humanity of a slave is in the past, and modern writers might struggle with analyses on the lived experience of a human commodity.

In the 1960s, a group of American economic historians began generating research called cliometrics, a sub-discipline of economics meant to (re?)integrate history and the quantitative side of economics. For about 15 years, cliometrics was popular, and then it wasn't; a scholarly fad in the cycle of academic inquiry, subject to reinvention in the future. The marriage of mathematical statistics to other disciplines has happened before: anthropology, psychology, and ecology among others. Cliometrics was near its peak with the 1974 publication of Robert Fogel and Stanley Engerman's Time On the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery. The release of the book was heavily critiqued, both for its analytic errors and perceived historic insensitivity. One such response was Herbert Gutman's Slavery and the Numbers Game (1975).



Gutman's main arguments focus on Fogel and Engerman's treatment of the slave work ethic, family life and sexual proclivities. Time on the Cross boldly states it aims to "strike down the view that Black Americans were without culture, without achievement and without development for their first two hundred and fifty years on American soil (258)."  In the authors' view slaves were hard-working, moralistic, and well-adapted to their station, centered solidly around the nucleus of the black family unit.  On the whole, the conclusion was that slaves were more efficient than their free laboring counterparts. Gutman allows that the authors describe a "transformation" of the slave to his new home, but fail in that they only fully describe the transformation and not the slave.

Other errors are repeatedly attacked in Gutman's text. Scant evidence and isolated examples are overused to make broad statements on slave mentality and lifestyle; ubiquitous and imprecise language pepper technical paragraphs; assumptions are presented as evidence; "slaves" and "blacks" are synonymous categories; the Sambo archetype is morphed into a black Horatio Alger to fit the explicit goal of the book (Gutman 16).  Gutman spends a large amount of space contesting Fogel and Engerman's "whipping" calculation as being too low an estimate and based on faulty methods. It is true that the math was not robust, but the (in)humanity of the event - however common it was - was completely ignored. What was the frequency of slave whippings? Where this a negative labor incentive? What was the effect of slave whippings on productivity and efficiency? These questions are attempted and answered by Fogel and Engerman. If a correct answer is found, is it the best answer to such a question?

Critiques on writing about lynching have similar demands. Historians such as Micheal Pfeifer urge researchers to keep the victim experience present when presenting metadata on mob violence, as there are lingering effects of that painful era still in the minds of many Americans. Those who sought "ritualized and racialized retribution" (The State of the Field of Lynching Scholarship, Pfeifer 835) incurred the cost of slavery as well, in terms of spiraling moral turpitude masked as "rough justice," and the descendants of the lynch mob just as the descendants of the slave therefore have a right to the counter-narrative.

The voice of the slave is still coming to light. Also in the 1960s, the scholarship of abuse literature took shape and since, we have been able to use that discipline as a lens to inspect past abuses. Nell Irvin Painter writes in Soul Murder & Slavery: Toward a Fully Loaded Cost Accounting (2002) that violence and "soul murder" are inseparable from slavery, where soul murder is defined as physical, sexual and/or mental abuse. To Painter, the social costs of slavery were absorbed by all races and parties (32) and evidence of this is abundant.

Slave agency in the face of racist capitalism will continue to be a poignant topic for economics, history and other subjects. One hopes that the scholarship will become increasingly more rigorous and representative as it gains validity and provides new insights to a the next generation of researchers further removed from a topic of significance to all Americans.


dls

1.25.2015

What's in a name? Coolies and Cane by Moon-Ho Jung (2006)

My first stop down a research wormhole into economic history was Moon-Ho Jung's 275-page manifesto, Coolies and Cane: Race, Labor and Sugar in the Age of Emancipation (2006, Johns Hopkins University Press). I'll be completely honest and admit I had no idea what a "coolie" was until this book was in my hands. Spoiler alert: no one during this era knew what a "coolie" was.



That's probably the major theme of the book: defining who's a coolie for purposes of legal and racial accounting. 

A Little Background
Set in the Gulf Coast region during the Civil War era, the impetus for the text was the burgeoning global sugar trade of the 19th century. Sugar has its origins of use in the far East, and through trade and pilfering via the Crusades, made its way to Europe, where over the course of a few hundred years, saw the construction of refineries in Italy in the 1400s. When Columbus sails to the New World on the eve of the 16th century, he takes a few sugar cane plants with him and [Sweet &] lo and behold, the agriculture blossoms in the Caribbean's ecosystem (pun intended). Mix this with the rise in European sea power and transnational imperialism and you get sweet tea. Joking. What resulted is large tracts of land in South America, the Greater Antilles and what became known as Louisiana being seized and colonized for this cash crop. And wherever there's profit to be made and natural resources to be fleeced in the era of big ships and empire-hungry nation-states, you have free labor.

One thing I learned is that "free labor" is not what it sounds like during the 19th century. Free labor to me has always been synonymous with slave "wages," i.e., nothing. Just working for free. However, from reading this book I was informed of Free Labor ideology of this time which was a direct contrast to slave labor. It espoused a Horatio Alger ideal of "pulling oneself up by one's bootstraps." An egalitarian vision of self-reliance that afforded anyone willing to work hard the keys to prosperity. Slaves on the other hand, weren't self-reliant. And in the early days of the United States, weren't completely human (see the Three-Fifths Compromise). So there's that.

In the 1800s the Gulf Coast was a melting pot of slaves and colonists and indigenous people all with different ideas on the "best" use of the land. The colonists got the jump on the other two, and specifically, the Spanish colony of Cuba proved particularly competitive, what with its tropical environment and lack of mountains. The terrain proved the best place to grow and export sugarcane. But the Portuguese, English and French were not to be outdone: the wealth from producing valuable sugar to export from the backs of slave labor was staggering. These massive fortunes funded even more massive estates back home. But let's not forget the slaves, who actually were human and therefore hated their involuntary and inhumane commoditization. So they rose and and rebelled. The revolution in France (1789-1799) strongly influenced another in its own colony of Saint-Domigue, (1791-1804), which resulted in the elimination of slavery and the commencement of the Republic of Haiti.

This very idea that slaves could be free, human and free laborers was perhaps even more potent that the act of emancipation itself. Across the Gulf Coast, black slaves began to push back with more concentrated frequency. If not by revolting, than by simply not caring. They refused to work, broke tools, ran off and otherwise resisted, making the use of black slave labor very worrisome for plantation owners.

Scientific Race Theory
Jung's text picks up here, with a demand for alternative plantation labor to produce and export sugar in the age of emancipation. "Africans" who were frustrated with slavery were broadly categorized as "indolent," "violent", "untutored" and disloyal in that they were the race "most easily influenced by a bribe" (Jung, 65). So who would work the fields? The infamous - and incorrect - theories of race and vocational hierarchies at the time were expressed in a widely circulated agricultural magazine out of New Orleans called De Bow's Review. In an article printed during the Civil War the periodical published the following: "We fight against nature's laws in seeking to impose tropical field labor on the white and olive races, and to release the black race from it....and we, moreover, violate true liberty in so doing" (Jung 66).



One answer to this was coolie labor. Importing laborers from the birthplace of sugar itself, Asia.

Scientific race theorists and other political opportunists could not classify Asian workers as black or white, and as such, sidestepped the messy ordeal of perpetuating slavery. But if the coolies were slaves, then could they be imported as factors of production? In the United States, the growing power war between Northern industrialists and Southern planters was centered around who could control Congress. The planters were numerous and rich, but their wealth and livelihoods were threatened by emancipation. Knowledge of this meant abolition spread quickly in the North, but to protect white, male political rights, rather than black human rights. Importing coolies helped to undermine the uncertainty of emancipation. However, importing anyone undermined emancipation. Still, American legislators shied away from allowing these workers to immigrate, as that would put them on the path towards naturalization, and that was reserved for whites. Noting the racial traits of the Asian workers, author Augustin Cochin wrote in his book The Results of Emancipation (1863) that the "East Indian" was comparatively "sober, more intelligent than the black, but less robust," while the Chinese were "generally robust and laborious" and acclimated to sugar cane production (Jung 66)"

So Chinese workers, who were not racially black or white, who were neither imports nor immigrants, but definitely not citizens, were acquired from "crimps" (Chinese body brokers), and transported by "clippers" (their American counterparts) to work the sugar cane plantations when blacks would no longer be forced to were "coolies."  Wow. That's a lot of work and words to describe slavery by another name.

Race and the Ideal Plantation Labor Force
Yeah, so the ideal plantation labor force is just that: an idea. It doesn't exist. And paradoxically, neither do coolies. Both were propaganda cooked up by overzealous imperialists obsessed with race to justify their own rent-seeking classist ambitions. First, the coolie proved to be just as human and conscious as the black, and by the end of Jung's book, are just as resistant to exploitation.  In his study on British Guiana, historian Walter Rodney argued that "to rely solely on planter propaganda would be to miss a hidden history of shared responses to common circumstances, regardless of race," (Jung 205). Second, efforts to deny the Chinese citizenship while demanding his labor (women were not transported to the U.S.) under strict, and often violently enforced contracts, left the door open for some form of emancipation for the coolie, that is, legal status as immigrants, a title reserved only for selective Europeans, again on a sliding scale, as all Europeans weren't created equal in the eyes of Americans either.

Jung's book is littered with legal precedents that were necessarily challenged by all parties. As the legal and illegal coolie trade grew alongside growing racial tensions, the influx of laborers led to our nation's first broadly restrictive immigration law, the 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act. Jung concludes his history of coolie labor there amidst a dynamic landscape of people, ideas, and goods in the years following Reconstruction. By this time the coolie had began to redefine himself away from the oppressive sugar plantations and into cities were "Chinatowns" were autonomous and thriving and even more foreign to white America. It would be another 61 years before the Chinese Exclusion Act would be repealed, and then only in the interest of boosting morale between the U.S. and China as allies against the Axis powers during World War II.





  

7.19.2013

BP cries "Wolf!"

The lawyers are lying.

My firm - The Delasol Group - has been intimately involved with the fallout from the 2010 BP oil spill. An NYC investment firm retained my services to provide economic literacy to the communities of color filing natural resource claims against the $20 billion BP fund. These are primarily Native American parishes whose economy depends on the vitality of the water itself. They are the cooks, the fishermen and the shrimp boat captains who keep Louisiana's vibrant seafood industry in high demand. 

I've been monitoring the (lack of) progress to make whole the fishing communities I encountered in the months after the incident. An immediate problem was verifying who should receive compensation. The most significant hurdle to the tribes was their practice of bartering their catch, rather than inducing the paper trail of bank transactions and receipts. How could BP prove they were victims?

Despite efforts to validate the claims by the infamous Gulf Coast Claims facility, fraud ran rampant. So BP cried "wolf" and this week has requested to freeze all claims to the BP fund until the Department of Justice can shakedown the Fund's lawyers, suspected of principal-agent fallacies.

In economies, a principal-agent problem arises when you (the principal) hire an agent to make decisions on your behalf, either because you can't or just won't. An agent might be the President of a country or your financial adviser or your babysitter. A problem arises when your agent doesn't do what you're paying them to do.

And therein lies the rub: we need the lawyers to defend the victims, but we can't trust the lawyers to do what we hire them to do.

The Delasol Group is concerned with the people who live on the water, at ground zero, who are struggling to make ends meet. If they can't earn income from what they pull from the Gulf, then how are they surviving? What other obstacles have arisen as a result of the loss in fishing revenues? Structural unemployment? Changes in consumption and diet? Higher retirement age? All of these have a well-defined economic impetus and consequence. If BP can't (or won't) help, can I?

dls

6.19.2012

All Day I Dream About Shackles (A.D.I.D.A.S.)

The world will never see the JS Roundhouse Mids, Adidas' most infamous shoe to date. Can you guess why?



After hearing news of the shoe on NPR this morning, it would have been silly to exclude it as a current event in my econ classes today. Students were learning about Keynes' theories on business investment. Back during the Great Depression era, the father of macroeconomics felt that fickle consumers were just that due to our "animal spirits." Businesses never know exactly what products will be profitable and what won't because of our dynamic tastes and preferences! So investment for companies - and people - always involves some measure of risk. 

Well Adidas took a risk alright. But how could a firm as successful as Adidas have missed the mark so badly? 

One argument is that the shackles are representative of imprisonment, and other notoriety from inmates (and slaves) have become fashionable, right? Like braids, over sized pants, chains, brands and tattoos. Granted, not all listed are simply fads; in other cultures, braids and body art can be a sign of position or rank. It is true however that in our urbanized milieu, sagging jeans, "over gold" and brands have become positives instead of negatives.


Never heard of  "over gold?" Play the video below for a 1 minute introduction. It's endemic.





Another argument is that the consumerist American culture likes high-priced goods, no matter how ignorant or hurtful or controversial it may be. One student remarked that Adidas usually sells its shoes for a fraction of the price of the JS Roundhouse (which would have sold for about $150.00). So he would have bought them just to have a limited edition (scarce) one-of-a-kind shoe.


Ultimately, Adidas decided to drop the shoe from its fall line because of negative backlash in the blogosphere; not because a prudent Adidas executive thought better of it. Why? Negative PR leads to losing market share to Nike. The guest on NPR said that while Adidas lost out on the investment, it was a small price to pay to attract more consumers.

It's all about the Benjamins, baby.

Not to mention that best argument of all: why would I want athletic shoes equipped with shackles?? To keep me from jumping and running? That's just dumb.


Your thoughts are welcomed. Prosperity!

@RogueEconomista

1.16.2012

Dr. King's Dream Today

"Beyond Vietnam" is a speech by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., that you probably have not heard of if you are an 80's baby like myself. It was the speech he received the most vitriol for. Delivered exactly one year to the day before his assassination in Memphis, TN, King vilified America for her negligence of the poor in lieu of an unpopular war. What economic value can we use today from King's vision in 1967? Is his message in this unpopular speech relevant?


Most notably from that speech, King quoted an important statistic: "We spend $500,000 to kill each enemy soldier while we spend only $53 for each person classifed as poor; and much of that $53 goes to people who are not poor. So I was increasingly compelled to see the war as an enemy of the poor..."

Per Google, the costs of killing an enemy combatant in the Iraq or Afghan wars range from $50 million to $150 million depending on when you compiled the data. However, our soldiers of all colors can sit in the same classroom and live on the same block in peace. But the income inequality is the issue that remains an issue.

I believe that Dr. King would support the #Occupy movements worldwide. In "Beyond Vietnam," King speaks against the war to break down the wall between not only black and white, Jew and Gentile, but also between capitalist and communist and every variation in between. Market structure is a non-factor in King's utopia. Capitalism may very well be an engine of income inequality; but inequality anywhere is injustice everywhere. So with the growing income inequality we have experienced here, the conclusion is that the American capitalist structure must be reformed.

King explicitly addresses the "giant triplets of racism, militarism and economic exploitation..." and says that true compassion will force us to examine our values, or our normative statements. Should we spend our money on national defense or moral uplift? Today, on January 16, 2012 , we ask ourselves this question. The war in Iraq is over as the war in Afghanistan rages on. In contrast, income security, i.e., welfare spending is roughly 12% of the national budget, or $5,777.64 per poor person.

"There will be no meaningful solution until some attempt is made to know these [poor] people, and hear their broken cries."

- Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., April 4, 1967



prosperity,

@RogueEconomista

1.11.2012

BP Must Pay

This week an Op-Ed piece ran in the NY Times which audaciously claimed that BP is the poster child for economic justice in industrial accidents. In response to the accident of 2010, a $20 billion fund to compensate victims of the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill was established and Kenneth Feinberg was appointed by the President to oversee compensation to the masses of households and businesses adversely affected. The NYT author takes pains to note that BP has "performed quite admirably" in the aftermath.

Oil & Water don't mix; BP Deepwater Horizon rig explosion response team


The Players
Last year, The Delasol Group established a working relationship with Fiduciary Management Group (FMG) to facilitate monetary distribution for Loss of Subsistence Use of Natural Resources; verbiage meaning that due to the oil pollution, there are people who can no longer eat food from the water, use the water in any functional capacity or go back to work if their vocation dealt with the water. This is a claim that affects households and small businesspeople in the region.

And that $20 billion to rebuild the Gulf Coast economy? As of Monday the following statistics (1) are predictably true:


The Numbers


  • 29.45% of the Fund has been paid out since inception in August 2010.
  • 61% of all compensation has gone to businesses.
  • There's a 64% chance an individual will receive $5,000 or less (grossly understating the value of loss).
  • Claiming Loss of Subsistence Use of Natural Resources comprises two-hundredths of one percent or .02% of all claims paid.


The Rub

Specifically, The Delasol Group and FMG are working alongside tribal leaders of the Biloxi-Chitimacha Confederation of Muskogees in Southern Louisiana. This is a population that falls short of the education and political clout to make easy work of the onerous documentation. The Delasol Group is a business which serves the disenfranchised. This is a population of skilled shrimpers, homemakers, oystermen, deck hands, administrative assistants boat operators and many others who deserve more than a cursory article; more than a federal oversight; more than an obliterated culture. Visit FMG's secondary website dedicated entirely to the cause to learn more about the firm's efforts and the BCCM website to read about the tribes' history, goals and concerns moving into the future.

The Mission

Should the Gulf Coast Claims Facility amend their erroneous processes to file and receive compensation for Subsistence Use claims of Natural Resources damaged by the BP Oil Spill, FMG will invest and allocate reward monies for current and future generations of the tribes. The Delasol Group will draft, publish and present and make permanently available economic literacy curricula sensitive to the tribe's socioeconomic needs to nurture and develop their assets.

In addition to muddied shores and tarred inlets, these citizens face off against both their own government and Big Business in a mutual quest of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness in an all too familiar standoff. To achieve tribal-level justice the American Indians are pitted against businesses and victims in competition for a bigger piece of GCCF pie. No litigation necessary; it's not their day in court these people strive for. They, like so many other disenfranchised Americans seek a day when their land, language and lifestyle are respected as any other.

I'd like to see the NY Times write a piece on the income inequality rampant among those who have received  GCCF payment and those who have not. Or an Op-Ed on the deleterious conditions marring a credible and accountable GCCF claim approval process. No, a follow-up on how the people in this video clip have improved economically with help from BP since this was filmed last March should do the trick.



BP has made amends for nothing until it has made amends for everything. The GCCF is as yet unsuccessful if it neglects even the least of victims. In the spirit of activist and theologian Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere (2)."



(1) Report obtained from the Gulf Coast Claims Facility website
(2) From King's Letter from Birmingham Jail, 16APR1963



@RogueEconomista

8.09.2011

Notes on a Scandal: Oil Spill Monsters

Rumor has it that the Global North - rich in human resources and ingenuity - has systematically exploited the Global South - rich in natural resources - for personal gain. This is not entirely true.



"Global South" and "Global North" are alternative designations for developing countries and developed nations, respectively. It's a nod to the United Nation's Human Development Index; a low score (<0.5) indicates there's room for economic and social improvement. The geographic location of said countries, however, is approximate: e.g., Nigeria (0.4) is technically in the Northern Hemisphere, as New Zealand (0.9) and Australia (0.9) are in the Southern.

The truth is that nations of the Global North have natural resources as do their Southern counterparts. However, an economic principle called Comparative Advantage allows some countries (in the Global North) to exploit the benefits of world trade (globalization), albeit often at the expense of each other (read: the Global South). So Florida becomes a major producer of oranges, although the citrus treat is indigenous to Asia. New agricultural methods, technology and lower costs can remarkably make "Florida oranges" a household name.



Oil doesn't make one think of the United Kingdom, but believe it or not, it's rich in it! Because of comparative advantage, it's cheaper for a country rich in applying the human resource to technology to import it from say, the Persian Gulf or the Niger delta. Since the early 1900s, the UK has had a presence in the global oil industry. Through a series of mergers & acquisitions over the years, we have present-day energy conglomerates BP and Shell. The two UK energy firms have had their share of ups and down in the global markets, including anathema to Big Oil: a spill. Or worse yet, an environmental catastrophe.  Volatile stocks, environmental damages and consumer confidence have left both firms humbled. Or has it?



BP:
  • Most recently claimed culpability in the Deepwater Horizon oil rig disaster last April. The Consequence: BP has to cough up $20 billion to compensate residents and businesses for the damaged coastline. The Rub: The claims & distribution process for victims is slow and unjust. Only 25% of the BP compensation fund has been paid out in the last year! Delasol filmed on location this Spring alongside a Native American community in Louisiana.
  • Profits: Up 21% from the previous quarter. Consider that rising commodity (gas) prices is a boon for BP; though this is only part of the story.
  • Production is down 11% from the same time last year. The company said the damage to its reputation as a result of the Gulf Oil Spill could hurt global business prospects now and in the future. Nonetheless, a new joint venture in India in is the works.
  • Share Price (BP) as of August 8th closed nineteen cents above $38 on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), hovering closest to it's 52-week low of $34.82 last August. Not a good indicator of investor confidence.

    this ad does not reflect the position of the delasol group, but it was both effective and apt.
    Shell:
    •  After considerable pressure from the United Nations and a lawsuit on behalf of a Nigerian king, the Royal Dutch Shell company has accepted liability for two oil spills that devastated a community's freshwater supply in 2008. At least 7,000 oil spills have occurred in the area since Shell first discovered the Niger delta oil in 1956.
    • Profits (for the second quarter) are up 97% from a year ago, again highlighting the industry's heavy dependence on retail oil prices.
    • Production is down year-on-year, but relative to its competitors, prospects are looking up for Shell. Although many oil-producing nations restrict the movement of Big Oil, there is hope in the profitability of the $20B Pearl project in the Persian Gulf state of Qatar.
    • Share price (RDSA) is doing relatively (to itself and other oil stocks) well and trading within an acceptable range for the stock on both the NYSE and the FTSE 100 index in the UK.
    So are oil spills a cause for shame or the impetus to fame? Shell has fared well while BP has struggled, but what's the end game for these firms? More production leads to higher profits and a greater number of environmental incidents. If handled ethically (and what is that?) Big Oil can bring the change we want to see. It seems to be a good start for Shell to own up to the land and it's people before its own bottom line.

    your comments are welcomed!
    dls