Showing posts with label Transportation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Transportation. Show all posts

7.19.2013

We Lost Detroit - America's Banana Republic

Gil Scott Heron called this one. 






Bridges and Breeders
The original 1977 track appeared on Heron's Bridges album, a nod to the 1975 novel of the same name, by John G. Fuller. But rather than the 800 lb. public finance gorilla in the room, the culprit 28 years ago was nuclear energy production.
Breeder reactors

The breeder reactor debuted in Detroit to improve upon existing nuclear energy efficiency. The day it was invented in Idaho in 1951, it could power four light bulbs. The following day, it could power the whole building. That's efficient.

The first commercial version broke ground in Lagoona Beach, Michigan in 1956 and went into operation in 1963. It shutdown three years later because the core was overheating and melting stuff that wasn't supposed to be melting. Nuclear meltdown pending until the operating license was denied in 1972. America never went that route again. The costs of a potential meltdown, not to mention the actual costs of disposing of nuclear waste and the money spent training and retaining employees in a high stakes environment far outweigh the benefits of nuclear production.

Well, we had "the big one" this week. From an economic standpoint, Detroit is gone. It is not productive. It spends way more than it generates. The city can only "come back" if it's bailed out to the tune of around $19 billion. The largest municipal bankruptcy filing. Ever. This is a rare event in America.

But if Detroit can't produce energy, it can certainly produce its complement: cars. Or at least it used to. Detroit is home to our nation's beloved automotive industry - also a controversial debtor in recent history - a former testament to the might of American capitalism. Detroit was a natural hub for the burgeoning car manufacturers since commodities such as copper, iron and coal were easily shipped there by water or land. Henry Ford gave the city its economic advantage with the founding of the Ford Motor Company in 1903 and the innovative assembly line that standardized car production forever. Creative destruction, technological progress, division of labor and economies of scale are just a few of those 'advantages.' Ford also paid relatively high wages, and by the 1940s had realized overt racial discrimination meant less profit, hiring more African Americans than most private firms in the nation at the time.

Well people haven't stopped driving cars yet, so what how did we lose the city?

Population flight is one reason. In 1950 the city had 1.8 million residents. That's declined to about 700,000 today. Back in 2010 I was working for the Census Bureau, and the big story surrounding the decennial survey was that Detroit's population decline averaged out to one person leaving the city every 22 minutes since the previous census in 2000. Wow. Some cities we expect to shrink. Like New Orleans. Or Chicago. In recent years, life hasn't been easy there. But Detroit has been shrinking for six decades. There are larger issues at play here.

The Banana Republic of Detroit

Motor vehicle sales are a key economic indicator of growth and have been since Ford and Olds established their empires, informally christening Detroit as the "Motor City." Car sales are directly related to attitudes and ability to spend money. When we feel optimistic about the economy we spend money. When we worry the economy is in free fall, we hold on to our cash. More car sales means Americans have more disposable income and - if considered a luxury purchase - indicates we're better off. When Ford and Olds would rev up their production lines, resources like people and machinery were instantly employed. Jobs were advertised and filled. Productivity and incomes rose and people started demanding things like better roads and bridges, more telephones and more cars.

Motor vehicle sales boomed from 1905 until World War I, when production decisions focused on war goods: tanks, planes and jeeps. By the 1920s most Americans had seen a car, and the market for first-time buyers was shrinking. Now we needed another one, indicating a shift in consumer tastes and preferences: a second car was a luxury purchase and meant that the household was allocating more time to leisure (road trips) or work (women employed outside the home). By 1929, GM, Ford and Chrysler - Michigan's Big Three - represented 75% of yearly auto sales in the United States. Traffic congestion grew and municipalities had to charge higher taxes to finance better infrastructure. Businesses and household moved to the relatively cheaper suburbs. Tourism exploded as cities vied to entertain the passing motorist.

The Great Depression hit the Detroit metropolitan area hard; so hard the unions took a firm foothold at the bargaining table for fair wages, hours and pensions for an out of work industry. Consumers weren't buying cars anymore. The auto industry in Michigan had grown too large to simply shut down. People's lives were at stake. The United Auto Workers fought for the survival of the Motor City's backbone.

World War II slowed auto sales as during its predecessor, but rebounded after the war ended. Beginning in the 1950s, environmental concerns began to gather steam. Seat belt laws and vehicle emissions regulations meant going back to the drawing board for the Big Three. In 1975, the fuel crisis necessitated legislation and more fuel-efficient production, particularly of smaller cars. In the 1980s, competition arose and foreign manufacturers introduced smaller Toyotas, Volkswagens and Mercedes. Union demands meant the cost of producing a small car simply wasn't worth it, so the Big Three threw their weight behind the intensely profitable SUV / light truck market in the 1990s.
a Ford SUV

We all know how that one ends. Foreign competition, eco-friendly consumer trends and the decline of unionism meant that SUV production was ultimately, a losing investment. All the eggs were loaded into the SUV basket and it couldn't combat the lower-priced shiny goodness coming out of Japan and Germany and South Korea. Foreign car manufacturers brought us compact, incredibly efficient vehicles that often run on alternative fuels. The Big Three were too big to pivot and follow suit; and too big to fail.

I think that auto sales were the harbinger of Detroit's financial collapse. We don't want to believe that the city  is a homegrown banana republic; only suited for producing cars. A 97% occupancy rate in the downtown/midtown area sways our emotions. But how to bring the people home? What will persuade them spend money in the business districts, pay taxes and, start new firms and demand jobs?

We lost Detroit.



dls







5.14.2012

By the seat of your gasoline underpants


So many of the decisions we make in our everyday lives can be discussed or predicted using economics. Here's a step-by-step example:

  • People desire (demand) gasoline. We use it in  our cars so we can go!
  • Gasoline comes from countries (mainly OPEC supplier) who seek profits and control distribution.
  • Because of  supply (OPEC) and demand (me and you) we sometimes faces ridiculously high gas prices!
Now we have a choice to make: Pay the higher price to ride around or refuse and stay home/carpool/take public transportation?


Choice

That's economics in action! When faced with any decision - from buying outrageously priced energy to choosing to go back to school - we weigh the benefits against the costs. Rational people will make decisions where the benefits are greater than or equal to the costs (I'll leave it up to you to decide if paying $4/gallon for gas is "rational" or not).

As of late, gas prices have slipped a tad. I filled up for $3.45 this weekend. Last summer I was surely paying in the $3.80s*. But 12 years ago when I left home for college, price per gallon was about $1.25 in Atlanta. What gives and who do I blame for all this volatility??

People like to point to years that gas prices were more "acceptable," then associate any changes (new President or frequent oil spills, for example) with ruining the good ol' days when prices were low. Not fair. Economics on the macro-level is indicative of the choices made by its myriad micro units. If we are more willing to pay $4/gallon, than we are to carpool, we're implicitly telling OPEC that the price is negligible. These countries will continue to earn greater profits as long as our demand stays the course! In this sense, demand creates supply and not the other way around. Sure OPEC has the best and the most oil, but it's worthless until a market for oil opens and flourishes. When cars begin to run on beer, expect to see Anheuser-Busch, Corona and Fat Tire merging to restrict supply and push up prices. It's just economics. We like gas and well, we like beer too. Prices will rise to see just how much we like them.



Custom made beer tap gas pump by GarageArt.com

But by how much will demand for gas rise as energy prices creep north? Economists use a measure called elasticity to answer this, but to keep from boring you to pieces, suffice it to say that gasoline is pretty inelastic: Americans don't respond to higher prices by demanding less gas. We just pay for it and keep pushing. But why?? One reason is that after adjusting the volatility of gasoline for inflation, we're in a place we've already been so it's not that big a deal (relatively speaking). Take a look at adjusted gas prices since 1919:



After accounting for inflation, I was right to feel great about gas prices in 2000 and in Atlanta, they were lower than the national avearge shown above. But these last twelve months are more like the late-1970s and early 1920s. It's not new or even excessively high; but it is very similar to the purchasing power Americans had in those eras. So spend like you know and stop acting so brand new. If your parents or (great)grandparents came of age during either of these times they may well have lacked the daily convenience of debit cards, extensive education (despite skin color), and personal automobiles. During these eras the nation had less debt and higher taxes as well.  Since they made it, how will you? What choices do you exercise when faced with increasingly higher energy bills?


Everything in perspective and moderation. Prosperity,

@RogueEconomista


* I use a handy application on my smartphone called Mileage to track how much bang I get for my buck. Very cool

1.24.2012

POTUS #StateoftheUnion '12

The annual State of the Union address. A major political event, economic increment and trending topic.

@RogueEconomista


Every year Americans await the President's take on the economy and where we're headed in the new year. Campaign years are especially important because voters can signal whether or not they are happy with the administration at the ballot box in November.

Previously, we've discussed the difference between positive and normative economic statements. This is never so tantamount as to when you are deciding which candidate, which party even, to vote for. Politicians have to pander to voters' preferences to get or stay in office. Their political promises, however, often lack the economic prudence to maintain our strong global standing with high production or low unemployment. Below, some highlights from President Obama's 2012 address that could have gotten lost in translation:


  • The Iraq War is over and thus commenced the President's speech. By ending the way America lowered her military expenditures and extended the lifespans of troops no longer challenged by Bin Laden's al-Qaeda. President Obama philosophically challenges us to imagine a world where we achieve economic growth without the aggressive use of national (preemptive) defense. It's a tough picture to paint: Americans have been at war constantly for the last 9 years and our economy has not emerged unscathed. This should be a major selling point for what follows...



  • "Everyone gets their fair share...everyone plays by the same set of rules..." President Obama calls this idea an American value, not one of only Republicans or Democrats. The idea of instituting equity or fairness into economics is a slippery slope: our experiences, lifestyles and beliefs shape our idea of what is right or wrong, fair or shady. This is a political promise, not an economic one. The markets don't promise fairness, only efficiency. There will be losers. And who determines what is fair? If there is in fact a "who" then we're not in Capitalist Kansas anymore. Welcome to the new State-Sponsored Capitalism. 

Where's the nose??
  • Domestic manufacturing is definitely a major bulletpoint of this year's speech. Surprisingly (to me) the President blatantly promoted protectionist strategies to promote domestic business at the expense of importing or producing goods and services cheaper elsewhere. I believe this to be problematic because by promoting America and putting down the rest of the world we are effectively cutting off our own nose to spite our lovely face. International trade helps us to grow beyond the resources we have. If we couldn't trade financial capital or democracy for oil then we'd have to change our way of life immediately. Also, producing goods and services at the lowest cost is a hallmark of competition and provides incentive for businesses to expand and evolve. This is more President political pandering: Obama is obligated to throw his support behind American manufacturing and production because he needs to be reelected this fall. In the long-run trade barriers such as "buying American" or subsidizing American producers hurts competition.  Suppose we protect our industries as the President suggest and prices are better elsewhere in the world? then cash flows will leave our country for more favorable markets; it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. Trade restriction are a highly controversial area especially during a time when domestic jobs are so scarce! But economically, what's better for America's future?

  • Aaah yes, and taxes. If anything the Buffet Rule is major political prose. The likelihood that we reform our complicated tax system anytime soon is slim to none. The likelihood that we reform taxes so they are more efficient, less obnoxious and well..fair? You do the math.


*sigh* And no word this year on moving closer towards faster, efficient public transportation like we see in technologically-advanced Europe and Asia. With rising gas prices and American protectionism we can  likely conclude that these constraints will constrict the economy and have an adverse effect on the job situation. People without income cannot pay high gasoline prices at the pump. They need high speed/long-distance trains, new buses, routes and stops, and metropolitan-wide light-rail systems to get them to where the jobs are. Oh, and more jobs will become available as we improve upon our nation's aged transit system to compete with other markets across the globe.

Love to hear your thoughts on this year State of the Union address!




1.25.2011

The State of the Union 2011

We revisit the President's annual address on what's going on in the U.S. and provide a briefing for busy ECONtrepreneurs.



After the opening preliminaries to thank us, shoutout the audience and squash partisan politics, he delved into some heavy positive (verifiable) and normative (opinion) economic information on Innovation that was broad in scope but riddled with detail.

President Obama rightly noted that technological advances have forever changed how we live, (look for) work, and play. While it's false that America is the largest and most productive economy (as based on Gross Domestic Product data, which is generally accepted in this country), it is true that the economy has escaped the snares of the recession and we are in the upswing of a recovery phase. This is the area of the business cycle that follows a downturn in economic activity. America is now progressing towards a new peak, led by corporate profits, net exports and (hopefully) employment. In the graphic below, "Real Output" is another name for the Gross Domestic Product.



Next, he considered our technological capacity to the education initiatives of boom economies such as India and Japan. While advances in gadgets and digital medium has largely contributed to U.S. economic growth over the last thirty years, India and China invested in their children, resulting in a smarter, more effective labor force. Consider the implications if America were to follow suit, coupled with our technology. Obama called for a reinvention of our energy policy to spearhead U.S. economic growth into the future. His vision is to develop the most able researchers and the most green policies on the planet. Think solar- or water-powered automobiles in the next decade. Not just more jobs, but more high-paying jobs. By 2035, he challenges the country to get 85% of its energy from renewable sources such as those just mentioned.

And speaking of education: it is positive information that investing in education is a predictor of the economic performance of a nation; we are more productive, live longer and engage in less crime. Race to the Top is an Executive-level initiative that provides monetary rewards for ideas to improve student achievement and teacher quality at the state level. Thrifty ECONtrepreneurs will dually be on the lookout for the now-permanent Tuition Tax Credits. A tax credit is an amount you are allowed to subtract from what you owe in taxes. So if you spend money on a student's expenses, you may qualify for the American Opportunity or the Lifetime Learning Tax Credit; incentives to consider the long-term implications of what higher education can do for you.



The President then went in on the ongoing debate on illegal immigration and demanded that we suffer the uncomfortable dialogue on national etiquette and policies to protect America's labor force and best economic interests, the nation of origin of the employee nonwithstanding. He normatively opined that kicking out the undocumented young intellegensia could result in vacant university seats or a decline in small business formation.

Infrastructure in the 2011 address now refers to both physical and digital innovations: American needs to improve both its interstates and information highways. Obama repeated a plea to push forward with plans to build a high-speed transportation system to compliment the high-speed internet which now transverses our country's citified and rural terrain. Public transportation investments can go a long way towards extending job mobility and business growth on the homefront.

The last point was a tricky one: to lower the corporate tax rate without adding to the deficit. How? Doubling exports by 2014, parterning with India, China and South Korea to add to the domestic workforce, enforcing our trade agreements (especially in the Asia-Pacific region), continuing to amend legislation as necessary to protect the American people (think health care and credit cards among others) and encouraging that "key word": Innovation. American exports are notoriously low compared to our imports, one big reason why our GDP (and therefore our productivity, as Obama pointed out) lacks behind that of the European Union.

Obama then began to speak in detail on how these ambitions could be reached, most notably a 3-year freeze in annual Federal spending, so as not to increase the deficit any more. The estimated savings, he warned, while good, will not be enough, so we much move to cut excessive spending wherever it is found, not just in the domestic arena. A powerful motivator for fledging ECONtrepreneurs who are seeking to maximize their futures, and not capitalize on the offerings of the present alone. While Medicare and Medicaid will likely take cuts, he wants to focus on continuing or increasing benefits for those Americans who require assistance to sustain themselves: retirees, the indigent and the impoverished. Other ambitions such as simplifying the tax code, keeping government progressive and of course, not allowing bipartisan politics to hinder our overall growth.

What can the State of the Union 2011 do for you?




cheers,

dls

5.22.2009

All Aboard!

Not since the early 20th century have so many Americans had train on the brain.


In 1922, General Motors President Alfred P. Sloan took the initiative to get more Americans into passenger cars by enlisting the help of Standard Oil (now Exxon), Phillips Petroleum, glass and rubber manufacturers and politicians to build a convincing argument against mass transit. America's love affair with the automobile has blossomed ever since...although the love affair with GM recently soured....



Economics has a special love for transportation issues too. There is lots of opportunity for creating more efficient, more economical modes of transportation. And, during economic downturns, more people tend to choose public transportation over incurring private transportation costs such as gas and maintenance. For an example as to how well public transportation can work, look at Spain.

Case Study: Spain by Train

After the success of Japan's Shinkansen Trains and France's TGV, Spain opened its first Alta Velocidad Espanola (AVE, for "high-speed Spanish train") in 1992. It ran between Madrid and Seville. Since then, the network has grown to include more stations in the south and eastern regions. In terms of efficiency and economy, the route handles about 89 percent of railway and air traffic. The number of tourists to smaller town has increased, demand for business conventions is up and less competitive-areas now have the option to attract companies to their local economies. Here's an interesting video on the efficiency and overall satisfaction with the AVE.



Trains have numerous economic benefits as a preferred mode of regional transportation. The International Union of Railways (IUR) says a high-speed train (which, by definition travels 90 m.p.h. or faster) can carry eight times as many passengers as an airplane over a given distance, using the same amount of energy and emitting a quarter of the carbon dioxide for each passenger. The AVE reaches up to 300 m.p.h. during the morning rush hours between Barcelona and Madrid.

With clogged highways and overburdened airports here in the States, economic growth is suffering. President Barack Obama has set aside $13 billion for high-speed rail infrastructure in his landmark 2009 Stimulus Package. That's an initial $8 billion, then $1 billion annually for five years. The Transportation Department is to begin awarding monies by the end of summer. As of today, only one high-speed rail line is operative in America; it's the Washington D.C. - Boston line in the Northeast Corridor. The Federal Government has identified 10 corridors nationwide with great promise for high-speed development.

President Obama has this to say on high-speed rail systems in the U.S.:
"What we need, then, is a smart transportation system equal to the needs of the 21st century. A system that reduces travel times and increases mobility, a system that reduces congestion and boosts productivitym a system that reduces destructive emissions and creates jobs."
So now that we understand the benefits, what are the costs? The director of high-speed rail at the IUR says that high-velocity trains are not profitable. Despite hugh time and environmental savings system-wide, budget airlines still offer the cheapest prices between Barcelona and Madrid and the IUR director goes on to say that the systems in Japan and France are likely the only two to have broken even in terms of profit. There are major concerns in terms of safety, and reliabilty which can be very costly to maintain. CATO Institute economist Randal O'Toole found that aside from businesspeople and tourist, average Europeans still prefer driving to rail transit. In an article that appeared in USA Today on May 20th, he confirmed that taxes would rise for all Americans and that ticket fares would cover only some of the operating costs and none of the capital costs. O'Toole calculates that the cost of implementing a high-speed rail system in the U.S. would cost an eye-popping $500 billion, in stark contrast to the $13 billion the President has set aside through 2015. American highway infrastructure paid for itself in a matter of years from fuel taxation. What besides rail subsidies would sustain a nationwide system?

One idea is property taxes. Spanish real estate portal Kyero reported in June 2008 that property prices in towns and cities served by AVE stations outperform their provincial averages. As more stations are planned, it will be interesting to see how the introduction of high-speed rail impacts house price. This could in turn become a primary source of payment for train systems worldwide.

What are your thoughts on high-speed rail in the U.S.?