Showing posts with label Expectations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Expectations. Show all posts

3.09.2015

Pleading the 14th Amendment: More Than Freedom by Stephen Kantrowitz (2012)

Spanning the years 1829-1889, black Americans' fight for freedom, and subsequently, citizenship, was in constant transition, and would continue to be well into the present-day. Although nominal citizenship was bestowed by the Federal Government via the 14th Amendment in 1868, the social, economic and political privileges that accompanied white citizenship were not that of "colored citizenship" during this era.



In his book More than freedom: Fighting for Black Citizenship in a White Republic, 1829-1889, author Stephen Kantrowitz writes that after the Civil War, the community of blacks in Boston, Massachusetts were instrumental in the "remaking of the postemancipation South" and pressed for "broader and more capacious laws of equal citizenship" while "insisting that whites who continued to exclude them by law or custom stood in opposition to the victorious Union and the egalitarian 'spirit of the age,'" (Kantrowitz 4). By stating that citizenship was validated both by law and by custom, Kantrowitz opens the door to the spectrum of equality in 19th-century America across race, class and gender. Whereas white male citizens had private property rights and suffrage, black males - and at a much slower rate, black women - were granted these rights in name only at first, and over time, made strides towards full engagement and respect in the milieu. Kantrowitz does adequately well in taking the time to discuss what black women activists were doing alongside the men, but several well-known female freedom fighters were left out, leaving to the imagination the concept of "citizenry' for a women. This book defines citizenship as being both the legal and social attainment of equal standing with any other (male) American.

Symbolically, blacks were squared off against the 'Slave Power' that had (for lack of a better word) enslaved white America since the 1700s. The Fugitive Slave Law of 1850 was the litmus test of citizenship in that non-citizens were slaves and only citizens could vote to repeal the law. Nonetheless, Kantrowitz displays black resistance during these year as well as during and after the Civil War. Between 1829 and 1860, blacks claimed their own citizen status by establishing their own institutions and meeting places such as churches, conventions, schools and lodges that housed the Prince Hall Freemasons, an organization that the author stresses in its significance. The Freemasons embraced principles of universal citizenship and white British members initiated the first black members in 1775 after they were previously rejected by colonial Freemasonries. In Boston, black nomenclature for self-identification presented the race as "African" first in the 1700s and later as "people of color" (1830s), "Negro," "colored Americans," "Africamericans," and occasionally as the "nominally free" (35). Consider also the fact that the Boston Public School System was desegregated in 1855 and a strong sense of black patriotism with frequent references to Crispus Attucks' martyrdom during the American Revolution. In fact, the source of inspiration for the struggle most present to Black Bostonians was the American Revolution and not the Haitian Revolution. Kantrowitz chooses to focus on the former, but in light of emancipation in contemporary societies, it would have enhanced the book even more to see how blacks were borrowing from or contributing to the global trend of freedom during this era. Black Boston was literate and engaged and perhaps historical documentation might connect them to the movement beyond their borders (domestic and international) in a meaningful and relevant way.

During the War years, blacks immersed themselves in military service to the objections of the law and white society. When blacks were not permitted to join the military (although they had served in previous wars) or the city militias, they created their own drill companies. With the passing of the Militia Act of 1862, blacks gained (nominal) citizenship and the employment opportunities afforded them by the military, although equal  pay with white laborers would be inferior for generations to come. After Emancipation, the passage of the 13th, 14th and 15th amendments freed the slaves, granted citizenship and voting rights, but the portion of Kantrowitz' book that deals with these years is appropriately titled "The Disappointments of Citizenship." The disappointment is that the fight for equality was only beginning and was perhaps, more heated and protectionist than before Emancipation. In that light, abolition was a "necessary but insufficient" stepping stone of citizenship, and Kantowitz is careful to delineate the abolitionist battles that ceased in 1864 from the activist battles that are perpetual.

Is this book a history of the path to citizenship for blacks in America? Or of the path to citizenship for black Bostonians? To a large extent, it is the latter, as Boston's geography, status as the crucible of American independence, and early establishment made it a petri dish for revolution and revolutionary ideas. In that sense, it's a community history of local characters with a shared goal. But to what extent did the revolutionary ideas of Black Boston resonates and reflect those of Blacks elsewhere? Did all blacks desire inclusion over segregation? There was likely division among Blacks in other states and territories over this point as as there was in Boston when the setting for change was the classroom. So in that sense, Kantrowitz' periodization and characterization of Black Boston can be extended more generally to the masses of enslaved and free Blacks of the time across the nation.

8.01.2014

La Argentina

Argentina is most recently famous for its World Cup athleticism in Brazil, losing only to the German team in the finals. And if you follow financial news, you know that Argentina has dropped the ball once again.

just out of reach

Back in 2001 I was an enlightened undergraduate and Argentina was in a deep economic depression. I was planning to study abroad in Buenos Aires from my home institution, Spelman College. I had been made aware of the dynamic environment on the ground in this south American nation, and having gotten into the routine of reading ten or more international newspapers a day, I was in the know.

Inflation. Street protests. Reneging. Riots. Daily breaking news briefs. Backpedaling governments. All excitement I was more than willing to stand at the tender age of 19.

I had grossly underestimated the gravity of the situation. Spelman hadn't. In the weeks before my departure I was provided a list of schools which still had openings for domestic exchange in the spring semester. Ugh. I mean I learned some important life lessons at Bryn Mawr, but it lacked the sexiness of a foreign nation.

All that to say that Argentina is no spring chicken. It's been to this dog and pony show before. Unable to pay the country's creditors it succumbed for the second time in my lifetime. For a sovereign nation, that's a recipe for even higher borrowing costs, just as would be the case for an individual who neglected to pay his or her debts. It's a lot harder to get cash when you need it in the future.

But individuals have a choice to borrow or not. We can change our lifestyle much easier than a nation can. We can train ourselves to save and pay down debts and refrain from swiping a credit card. But nations are the sum of their citizens and their myriad back habits. It's hard, I mean really hard to stop that train from moving. Ask Greece. Not even a year ago, America stood on the brink of default and devastation. Advanced nations imploding economically under the weight of debt is less an outlier and more the trend.

Keep your eye on who's leading the tango: Argentina says it was in their best decision not to pay the $29 billion it owes to outside investors (it missed a 30-day grace period to pay an interest payment to the tune of $539 million on Wednesday). But optimists suggest that a deal can be reached between bondholders and national leadership.

The 2001 default and this current one are closely intertwined. The hands that lent money then were never made whole and won't give up their claim.

Is the Argentine government to be blamed for this collapse? Are nations - like people -expected to honor contracts to borrow money? Should nations and people be so inclined to borrow in the first place? What's the alternative?

dls






7.19.2013

We Lost Detroit - America's Banana Republic

Gil Scott Heron called this one. 






Bridges and Breeders
The original 1977 track appeared on Heron's Bridges album, a nod to the 1975 novel of the same name, by John G. Fuller. But rather than the 800 lb. public finance gorilla in the room, the culprit 28 years ago was nuclear energy production.
Breeder reactors

The breeder reactor debuted in Detroit to improve upon existing nuclear energy efficiency. The day it was invented in Idaho in 1951, it could power four light bulbs. The following day, it could power the whole building. That's efficient.

The first commercial version broke ground in Lagoona Beach, Michigan in 1956 and went into operation in 1963. It shutdown three years later because the core was overheating and melting stuff that wasn't supposed to be melting. Nuclear meltdown pending until the operating license was denied in 1972. America never went that route again. The costs of a potential meltdown, not to mention the actual costs of disposing of nuclear waste and the money spent training and retaining employees in a high stakes environment far outweigh the benefits of nuclear production.

Well, we had "the big one" this week. From an economic standpoint, Detroit is gone. It is not productive. It spends way more than it generates. The city can only "come back" if it's bailed out to the tune of around $19 billion. The largest municipal bankruptcy filing. Ever. This is a rare event in America.

But if Detroit can't produce energy, it can certainly produce its complement: cars. Or at least it used to. Detroit is home to our nation's beloved automotive industry - also a controversial debtor in recent history - a former testament to the might of American capitalism. Detroit was a natural hub for the burgeoning car manufacturers since commodities such as copper, iron and coal were easily shipped there by water or land. Henry Ford gave the city its economic advantage with the founding of the Ford Motor Company in 1903 and the innovative assembly line that standardized car production forever. Creative destruction, technological progress, division of labor and economies of scale are just a few of those 'advantages.' Ford also paid relatively high wages, and by the 1940s had realized overt racial discrimination meant less profit, hiring more African Americans than most private firms in the nation at the time.

Well people haven't stopped driving cars yet, so what how did we lose the city?

Population flight is one reason. In 1950 the city had 1.8 million residents. That's declined to about 700,000 today. Back in 2010 I was working for the Census Bureau, and the big story surrounding the decennial survey was that Detroit's population decline averaged out to one person leaving the city every 22 minutes since the previous census in 2000. Wow. Some cities we expect to shrink. Like New Orleans. Or Chicago. In recent years, life hasn't been easy there. But Detroit has been shrinking for six decades. There are larger issues at play here.

The Banana Republic of Detroit

Motor vehicle sales are a key economic indicator of growth and have been since Ford and Olds established their empires, informally christening Detroit as the "Motor City." Car sales are directly related to attitudes and ability to spend money. When we feel optimistic about the economy we spend money. When we worry the economy is in free fall, we hold on to our cash. More car sales means Americans have more disposable income and - if considered a luxury purchase - indicates we're better off. When Ford and Olds would rev up their production lines, resources like people and machinery were instantly employed. Jobs were advertised and filled. Productivity and incomes rose and people started demanding things like better roads and bridges, more telephones and more cars.

Motor vehicle sales boomed from 1905 until World War I, when production decisions focused on war goods: tanks, planes and jeeps. By the 1920s most Americans had seen a car, and the market for first-time buyers was shrinking. Now we needed another one, indicating a shift in consumer tastes and preferences: a second car was a luxury purchase and meant that the household was allocating more time to leisure (road trips) or work (women employed outside the home). By 1929, GM, Ford and Chrysler - Michigan's Big Three - represented 75% of yearly auto sales in the United States. Traffic congestion grew and municipalities had to charge higher taxes to finance better infrastructure. Businesses and household moved to the relatively cheaper suburbs. Tourism exploded as cities vied to entertain the passing motorist.

The Great Depression hit the Detroit metropolitan area hard; so hard the unions took a firm foothold at the bargaining table for fair wages, hours and pensions for an out of work industry. Consumers weren't buying cars anymore. The auto industry in Michigan had grown too large to simply shut down. People's lives were at stake. The United Auto Workers fought for the survival of the Motor City's backbone.

World War II slowed auto sales as during its predecessor, but rebounded after the war ended. Beginning in the 1950s, environmental concerns began to gather steam. Seat belt laws and vehicle emissions regulations meant going back to the drawing board for the Big Three. In 1975, the fuel crisis necessitated legislation and more fuel-efficient production, particularly of smaller cars. In the 1980s, competition arose and foreign manufacturers introduced smaller Toyotas, Volkswagens and Mercedes. Union demands meant the cost of producing a small car simply wasn't worth it, so the Big Three threw their weight behind the intensely profitable SUV / light truck market in the 1990s.
a Ford SUV

We all know how that one ends. Foreign competition, eco-friendly consumer trends and the decline of unionism meant that SUV production was ultimately, a losing investment. All the eggs were loaded into the SUV basket and it couldn't combat the lower-priced shiny goodness coming out of Japan and Germany and South Korea. Foreign car manufacturers brought us compact, incredibly efficient vehicles that often run on alternative fuels. The Big Three were too big to pivot and follow suit; and too big to fail.

I think that auto sales were the harbinger of Detroit's financial collapse. We don't want to believe that the city  is a homegrown banana republic; only suited for producing cars. A 97% occupancy rate in the downtown/midtown area sways our emotions. But how to bring the people home? What will persuade them spend money in the business districts, pay taxes and, start new firms and demand jobs?

We lost Detroit.



dls







7.28.2012

XXX Olympiad: Time Well Spent

...money, not so much.

This is an Olympic event in and of itself
Economics recognizes time as a valuable resource. We spend it just like we spend money (and if you're fortunate, you've been endowed with more time than money!). As with any resource, it's scarce and thus, valuable; so we should be mindful of how we use it.

Athletes, coaches, sponsors and event staff are putting in unimaginable amounts of time to ensure that those of us at home can indulge in the XXX Olympiad for virtually no cost*. So who pays to put on the Olympics and is it worth it?

Hosting an international sporting event is big business. However, most of the "boom" is temporary: employment, construction, security, tax revenues and local retail sales are well-documented examples. In 2010, the World Cup in South Africa (read my take on it here) was an economic "bust." FIFA, the governing body for soccer on the planet is a not-for-profit group that took in $4 billion that year at the expense of the South African economy. The International Olympic Committee (IOC), also not-for-profit, will laugh all the way to the bank too.

Let's start with the bidding process. A decade before an olympiad, (the 4-year period surrounding the Olympic season) cities begin drafting plans to put on the biggest, brightest most efficient games. But in the bidding process, efficiency is often overshadowed by the minority goals of the local organizing committee. They are motivated by the private benefits rather than public costs! And never mind receiving the bid, just campaigning for it is a significant expense in and of itself. Chicago lost the 2016 bid to Rio de Janeiro for the Olympics, but still spent $100 million in the process.

After the IOC chooses a winner, an already bloated budget blows up even more as city planners hustle to make it happen. In some cases, such as South Africa and Athens (2004), the construction infrastructures are sorely needed to bring a city up-to-date. But in the wake of the event, the buildings often go unused, surrounded by weeds and dust rather than people and commerce. Beijing's energy efficient Bird Nest is the latest white elephant on the world stage.

Beijing's green & white elephant
Total revenue from an Olympics is about $4-5 billion these days, about half of which goes to the IOC, (who in turn distributes 90% to support the staging of the games). Even still, public financing (government borrowing) is almost always necessary. A notable exception is Los Angeles in 1984. L.A. was the only city on the planet willing to host the games, so they could bargain with the IOC for a more reasonable budget that didn't require taking on new debt. In contrast, the costs of the Olympics typically reaches into the tens of billions ($16 billion in Athens, $40 billion in Beijing) most of which is financed by debt and reasonably spent on security. No surprise there, after the horrific 1972 Munich games and the 1996 blast that ripped through Atlanta's Centennial Park. In the days leading up to the opening of such a high-profile event, terrorism fears can greatly increase the size of the budget.

And finally, we can't forget about sponsors. The Olympic Partner (TOP) program will bring in about $2 billion of the total revenue. Business' bid for the right to use the 5-ring Olympic symbol and basically capitalize off the games. This year, the world has witnessed the construction of the largest Mickey D's ever in London which will seat 1,500 and employs scores of people, only to be recycled and razed in six weeks. A waste or a good idea?

The world's largest McDonald's opens 7/28/2012

Without a doubt the Olympics are worth the time and effort to bring together the people of the world, and they are fun! But do you think the financial costs outweigh the feel good benefits? I'd love to hear your thoughts!

Here's a link to the official website of the Olympic Movement for more information on the nuts and bolts of the games.



Prosperity,

@RogueEconomista







*Save the costs of cable, internet, satellite and/or gas to get to your favorite pub to watch the games

6.19.2012

All Day I Dream About Shackles (A.D.I.D.A.S.)

The world will never see the JS Roundhouse Mids, Adidas' most infamous shoe to date. Can you guess why?



After hearing news of the shoe on NPR this morning, it would have been silly to exclude it as a current event in my econ classes today. Students were learning about Keynes' theories on business investment. Back during the Great Depression era, the father of macroeconomics felt that fickle consumers were just that due to our "animal spirits." Businesses never know exactly what products will be profitable and what won't because of our dynamic tastes and preferences! So investment for companies - and people - always involves some measure of risk. 

Well Adidas took a risk alright. But how could a firm as successful as Adidas have missed the mark so badly? 

One argument is that the shackles are representative of imprisonment, and other notoriety from inmates (and slaves) have become fashionable, right? Like braids, over sized pants, chains, brands and tattoos. Granted, not all listed are simply fads; in other cultures, braids and body art can be a sign of position or rank. It is true however that in our urbanized milieu, sagging jeans, "over gold" and brands have become positives instead of negatives.


Never heard of  "over gold?" Play the video below for a 1 minute introduction. It's endemic.





Another argument is that the consumerist American culture likes high-priced goods, no matter how ignorant or hurtful or controversial it may be. One student remarked that Adidas usually sells its shoes for a fraction of the price of the JS Roundhouse (which would have sold for about $150.00). So he would have bought them just to have a limited edition (scarce) one-of-a-kind shoe.


Ultimately, Adidas decided to drop the shoe from its fall line because of negative backlash in the blogosphere; not because a prudent Adidas executive thought better of it. Why? Negative PR leads to losing market share to Nike. The guest on NPR said that while Adidas lost out on the investment, it was a small price to pay to attract more consumers.

It's all about the Benjamins, baby.

Not to mention that best argument of all: why would I want athletic shoes equipped with shackles?? To keep me from jumping and running? That's just dumb.


Your thoughts are welcomed. Prosperity!

@RogueEconomista

4.17.2012

The Rain in Spain

...falls mainly on the plains; but let's be "fair" (pun intended). It's storming cats and dogs in the Spanish economy right now.



What's all the ruckus with high bond yields in Spain? And does that have anything to do with the less-than-stellar numbers the stock market posted on Friday?

In truth, Spain is making financial choices more difficult for everyone as of late. Worldwide media has got its panties in a bunch over high interest rates on the Iberian Peninsula: first Portugal, now Spain. High interest rates mean the same thing for nations as it does people: it's the cost of  the money you want when you have bad credit. The lender is obviously willing to take a HUGE risk so they are rewarded (and you are penalized) with high interest. In the movies, it's this convenient borrowing cost that's obnoxiously high enough to prevent full re-payment, prompting mobsters to dismantle your kneecaps.

Well, the rain is pouring down in Spain and that ship has sailed. The security to watch is the benchmark 10-year  bond. Most advanced economies offer this particular bond and many others that mature sooner or later than 10 years. In theory, "good" governments should allow for productive economies where people have jobs and earn income, spend and save; wash and repeat. Even better if they can choose where they work and what they buy. Under the productive economy assumption, even if governments run national deficits, it can borrow, issue bonds and ramp up production to pay the money back. In theory. In Spain's case, they spent way more than the Spaniards could produce so the deficits got bigger and bigger. The result is a mountain of debt, lots of excess capacity, high interest payments, and very very strict measures to get the economy back on track. Greece and Portugal are experiencing this now! And the citizens are none too happy about it because that involves pay freezes, layoffs and benefit reductions. Dessert or disaster after your rounds of spending? Disaster you say? Done.

Government debt is seen as a "safe" alternative to, say, stocks because again, economies should be stable and dependable, so returns are less risky. U.S. Treasuries are a famous "safe haven" for your money. Sure, our credit is crap, but we're the largest, most productive economy on the planet so you know...we're good for it. Whereas Spanish bond yields on 10-year debt is higher than 6%, U.S. 10-years are just around 2%. Night and day. Rain and sunshine.



The movement of bond yields (returns) reflects investor sentiment: literally, how investors feel. Investors wear their hearts on their sleeves. They take risks, but they don't really want to lose money. Fact is, it's inevitable. But no one wants to lose, so when Spanish debt becomes a liability, investors run in the other direction and expect the worse. Recession in the Euro Zone and the U.S. have left investors with weak stomachs. Thus, Spain's recent tumble into fiscal turmoil inspired investors worldwide to fly the straight and narrow and reallocate into the safe arms of U.S. government debt.

The adverse consequence is that money not only left Spain, but also U.S. stock markets, also seen as riskier  investments than government bonds. More than likely, your retirement account or other investments probably took a dive just before the weekend. Personally, my portfolio - which is disproportionately weighted in stocks for growth..I think.. - took a 1% hit that I'm not too pleased about. It's given that our world is a wide web of connections, so not only do we share the resources, but we also have to share the risks and the consequences of of economic decision-making. As the United States debates federal spending, debt ceilings and new leadership, voters are wise to become informed and self-aware! Have you noticed any negative changes in your stock portfolio as of late?


prosperity,

@RogueEconomista aka dls